Research Paper Writing Advice
My analogy here with Mozart is just that here hundreds of years after Mozart died we are listening to people read his papers or more precisely plays music where if you go to concert halls to hear his papers because their ideas were so infectious don’t you think that’s amazing wouldn’t it be remarkable if in 400 years’ time people were still reading your papers it’s not all that likely, but I think that’s kind of idea that you’d like to get your research paper is not a mechanism for getting promotion it’s a mechanism for conveying ideas from your head to somebody else’s head if you don’t convey them. Like if you don’t bother to tell anybody about your ideas then you might as well not have them.
Even if Einstein had sat in a windowless box and not told anybody about relativity then we wouldn’t know about relativity right that means you need to know what your idea is right so when you write a paper in the end at least by the time you’ve finished you must know what is the idea that your paper conveys it’s surprising how hard that can be to determine from people’s papers as a reviewer if you read somebody’s paper when you finished.
You can say what idea did that paper convey if you find that hard to articulate as a reader then you know you in your view can say I really couldn’t figure out what this what the idea this paper was about and so then you apply that to your own papers right it’s actually sometimes quite hard to know exactly what your idea is to begin with but you must know by the time you finished.
If you find it yourself thinking well actually three ideas in this paper, then what you do just write three papers like well then try to wedge them all in in which case each one becomes cryptic and incomprehensible because you try to write it into ten pages just like three papers that’s cool right that’s not salami slicing that is taking ideas in expressing them a good idea in your paper is to say explicitly when you get to the main idea it’s surprising how seldom this happens.