Thursday, March 29, 2007

Boys will be boys will be sociopaths

A recurring theme on computer science blogs is what might be done to encourage more women to enter (or remain in) the field, and to promote more diversity in general. For example, a recent post at On being a scientist and a woman talks about why women leave the academic career path (this is for science generally, but I'm sure it applies equally well to comp sci). As difficult as the academic world may be, however, it appears that things can be much worse for women working on the 'nuts and bolts' side of the aisle. Blogger and author Kathy Sierra writes about how email and blog sexual harassment and death threats have caused her to cancel a public appearance and step back from blogging. (Warning, that linked post contains material that is not appropriate for kids.) There are by now hundreds of posts by others providing commentary on this; some background information on the people involved is given by Doc Searls.

One weird thing about the whole situation is that the harassment grew out of a couple of websites set up by peers of Kathy Sierra, specifically for the purpose of being critical of, and generally nasty about, other technology authors. (The actual death threats appear to be from an interloper who hacked the identity of one of the participants.) Death threats and misogyny aside, why does the internet seem to spawn such general nastiness? Okay, that's a naive question. More to the point, does the anything-goes atmosphere encourage misogyny and racism and other bad stuff, or is that something totally apart from general snarkiness found on the internet? For example, on a site like ScienceBlogs, more than a bit of gratuitous obscenity and sarcasm can be found mixed in with the science and analysis, but it is a very progressive site where any hint of sexism or racism is liable to get smacked down hard.

Still, sexism does seem to be a particular problem within the tech community. Robert Scoble writes in response to Kathy Sierra's problems,
It’s this culture of attacking women that has especially got to stop. I really don’t care if you attack me. I take those attacks in stride. But, whenever I post a video of a female technologist there invariably are snide remarks about body parts and other things that simply wouldn’t happen if the interviewee were a man.

It makes me realize just how ascerbic this industry and culture are toward women. This just makes me ill.

Update

Well, the response on the blogosphere to Kathy Sierra's post has been, as you might imagine, enormous. I get the impression that Sierra would, with the benefit of hindsight, have responded to the threats a bit differently. However, some good might come out of all the brouhaha. Publisher Tim O'Reilly is calling for a blogger code of conduct that would help maintain a certain level of civility in web discussions. I think that could be a tough sell, but just raising people's consciousness about the problem may help.

It looks like Kathy Sierra and one of the other involved bloggers, Chris Locke, will be on CNN Monday morning. Should be an interesting segment a couple of minutes of soundbites with little content.

Labels:

2 Comments:

At 4/01/2007 04:12:00 AM, Blogger Tyler DiPietro said...

I think that the nature of the internet is such that it makes manifestations of our thoughts and emotions just so much easier, removing the natural layers of filtration that usually exist in meatspace.

I think a good example is when I deleted my blog, which is a decision I regret more and more every day. It seemed relieving when I first did it, and even a bit liberating. But the relief was mild and short lived. I'm diagnosed manic-depressive, and was experiencing episodic cycling during those times and couldn't figure out what was going on. It all just felt so fragmented. So deleting my blog was probably more along the lines of satisfying a self-destructive impulse than any rational decision.

Death threats can be the same way. People think it's entirely inconsequential. I have had several events in my online life that have demonstrated to me that there are real people out there on the intertubes, but I guess most people haven't benefited from such things.

 
At 4/02/2007 11:42:00 AM, Blogger Kurt said...

I can understand why some bloggers choose to remain anonymous. But I find that when I know a little bit of someone's personal background - what kind of work they do, where they're located, what they look like - it's easier for me to relate to what they are saying. (One of these days I'll get around to updating my own profile to provide some more info...)

I've made a few comments on other blogs that I've had second thoughts about (but hopefully nothing that people found offensive), but they were not made anonymously. The only times I make anonymous comments are when I suspect that I'm about to say something really stupid. We all have our vanities.

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home